Interesting article at NPR’s Goats and Soda by Nurith Aizenman. It discusses the concept of parachute researchers “Scientists from wealthy nations who swoop in when a puzzling disease breaks out in a developing country”
Researchers drop in. They take specimens. And they head home and don’t share. That’s no way to fight an epidemic. Can they do things differently when it comes to Zika?
Source: Scientists Fighting Zika Vow To Stop Parachute Research, Share Discoveries Quickly And Widely : Goats and Soda : NPR
It is of relevance to some of the discussions we have been having on the ICIS project regarding biopiracy and the risks of the commons. Although I note – I think this article did not quite get into a key aspect of the issue which is that even if researchers share everything there are still possible risks for the countries where samples have been taken. This may be a major topic for a future ICIS meeting so stay tuned.
Thursday, March 31, 2016, 3pm to 6:00pm
Activities and Recreation Center (ARC), Meeting Room 1
Frontiers is a leading Open Access scholarly journal publisher, with 55 journals in many disciplines and growing. In addition to rising journal Impact Factors, Frontiers is advancing article-level and author metrics as new ways of measuring the impact of research. A growing number of UC Davis faculty members edit Frontiers journals and have gained experience with this new publishing model and its benefits and challenges for publishing research. Join us for a look at the benefits of Open Access publishing for improving research impact through increased citations, and a cross-disciplinary panel of five UC Davis editors, on how Frontiers has worked in practice.
MacKenzie Smith, University Library (moderator)
Neelima Roy Sinha, Plant Biology
Cecilia Giulivi, Molecular Biosciences & Vet Med
Patrice Koehl, Computer Science & Genome Center
Mary M Christopher, Vet Med Pathology, Microbiology & Immunology
Arne Ekstrom, Psychology
Sandra Hausmann, Frontiers
A presentation and panel will be followed by a networking reception from 5:00-6:00pm
Christopher Kelty (UCLA) gave a fascinating talk for the Provost’s Forums on “Open Access, Piracy, and Scholarly Publication” on March 16, 2016.
Another interesting post relating to open access in Inside Higher Ed: The Fix Isn’t In | Library Babel Fish
It is by Barbara Fister and discusses some of her thoughts, as a librarian, on Sci-Hub.
Thanks again to Art Shapiro for pointing me to this.
I am still not sure how I feel about SciHub. I like that people can get access to more literature. But I would prefer that that happened by legal means and I think I agree with Fister that this is “not the fix for the mess we’re in.”
Anyway – the post is worth a look.
A post of possible interest at Inside Higher Ed. By Ernesto Priego: Open Access Reinterpreted | University of Venus
Thanks to Art Shapiro for sending this to me.
Lots of interesting points and also an interesting response from Bjorn Brembs. Definitely worth a look.
AUTHORSHIP AND THE PROMISES OF DIGITAL DISSEMINATION
March 9, 4:00- 5:45 pm
UC Davis School of Law, King Hall, Rm 2100A
A cross-disciplinary panel discussion on authorship in the digital age, with a focus on the specific goals and needs of academic authors. Authors who write to be read care about how their works are published and what that means for reader access. While traditional options and copyright arrangements still predominate in many fields, there are ever-increasing ways to share works of authorship. What works best to get textual and visual works out there and under what circumstances? Join us for this panel discussion with Authors Alliance, where we will explore the opportunities and challenges authors face in maximizing the reach of their work, both in and outside of academia.
Mario Biagioli (Law, STS)
Stephanie Boluk (English)
Jonathan Eisen (Biology)
Alexandra Lippman (STS)
Rick Prelinger (UCSC and director of the Prelinger Archive)
Kim Stanley Robinson (Mars Trilogy)
Pam Samuelson (Authors Alliance)
MacKenzie Smith (Library)
Madhavi Sunder (Law)
Michael Wolfe (Authors Alliance)
Davis Humanities Institute
Institute for the Social Sciences
Center for Science and Innovation Studies
Innovating Communication in Scholarship Project
UC Davis School of Law
Please follow the links to watch videos of the conference proceedings of “Gaming Metrics: Innovation and Surveillance in Academic Misconduct” held at UC Davis February 3-4th, 2016.
Welcoming remarks (Ralph Hexter, Provost, UC Davis)
FROM PUBLISH OR PERISH TO IMPACT OR PERISH (Mario Biagioli, STS & Law, UC Davis)
GAMING THE GAME ACROSS THE BOARD
- Timothy Lenoir (UC Davis, Cinema and Digital Media & Science and Technology Studies) (Chair)
- Alex Csiszar (Harvard University, History of Science) “(Gaming) Metrics Before the Game”
- Paul Wouters (Leiden University, Science and Technology Studies) “The Mismeasurement of Quality and Impact”
- Karen Levy (NYU, Media, Culture, and Communication) “Networks of Resistance in Trucking”
UNIVERSITY RANKINGS: GAMING OR COOKING?
- Martin Kenney (UC Davis, Human Ecology) (Chair)
- Barbara Kehm (University of Glasgow, School of Education Robert Owen Centre for Education Change) “Global University Rankings: Impacts and Applications”
- Lior Pachter (UC Berkeley, Mathematics) “How King Abdulaziz University Became a ‘Better’ University than MIT in Mathematics”
- Daniele Fanelli (Stanford University, METRICS) “Institutional Pressures to Publish: What effects do we see?”
PERSONAL V. INDUSTRIAL CHEATING
- MacKenzie Smith (UC Davis, University Librarian) (Chair)
- Finn Brunton (NYU, Media, Culture, and Communication) “Making People and Influencing Friends: Citation Networks and the Appearance of Significance”
- Sarah de Rijcke (Leiden University, Science and Technology Studies) “System Identity: Predatory publishing as socio-technical disruption”
- Jeffrey Beall (University of Colorado, Denver, Information Science) “Fake Impact Factors and the Abuse of Bibliometrics”
- Dan Morgan (University of California Press, Collabra Project) “Cui Bono? Judging Intentions (and Outcomes) of Personal and Industrial Cheating”
META GAMING, META CHEATING
- Anupam Chander (UC Davis, Law) (Chair)
- Johan Bollen (Indiana University, School of Informatics and Computing) “From Bibliometric Metrics to Crowd-Sourced Science Funding Systems”
- Carl T. Bergstrom (University of Washington, Biology) “It’s All a Game: The twin fallacies of epistemic purity and a scholarly invisible hand”
- Jennifer Lin (Crossref) “Trust through Transparency: O brave new world/ That has such data in’t!”
- Michael Power (London School of Economics, Accounting) “Research Impact and the Logic of Auditability: Solicited testimony as a case of meta-gaming”
- James Griesemer (UC Davis, Philosophy) “Taking Goodhart’s Law Meta: Gaming, Meta-Gaming, and Hacking Academic Performance Metrics”
Welcoming Remarks (Kevin Johnson, Dean, UC Davis School of Law)
MISCONDUCT WATCHDOGS (I)
- Jonathan Eisen (UC Davis, Genome Center) (Chair)
- Ivan Oransky (Retraction Watch & NYU) “Retraction Watch: What We’ve Learned Since 2010”
- John Bohannon (Science Magazine) “Grey Hat Hacking for Science”
- Elizabeth Wager (Sideview) “Why Do We Need a Committee on Publication Ethics and What Should It Do?”
MISCONDUCT WATCHDOGS (II)
- Jonathan Eisen (UC Davis, Genome Center) (Chair)
- Darren Taichman (Executive Deputy Editor, Annals of Internal Medicine Vice President, American College of Physicians) “A False Sense of Security?”
- Debora Weber-Wulff (University of Applied Sciences Berlin, HTW, Media and Computing & VroniPlag Wiki) “Documenting Plagiarism in Doctoral Theses: The Work of the VroniPlag Wiki Academic Community in Germany”
- Brandon Stell (The PubPeer Foundation & CNRS) “Introducing PubPeer”
- Emmanuel Didier and Catherine Guaspare (EPiDaPo, UCLA) “The Voinnet Affair: New Norms in High-Pressured Science”
COUNTERFEITING BRANDS V. FAKING PRODUCTS
- Madhavi Sunder (UC Davis, Law) (Chair)
- Marie-Andree Jacob (Keele University, Law) “Template, Creativity and Publication Ethics”
- Alessandro Delfanti (University of Toronto, Institute of Communication, Culture, Information and Technology) “ArXiv or viXra? Physics and the quest for the true archive”
- Sergio Sismondo (Queen’s University, Philosophy) “Leveraging Academic Value in the Pharmaceutical Industry”
- Alexandra Lippman (UC Davis, Innovating Communication in Scholarship) (Chair)
- Cyril Labbé (Joseph Fourier University – Grenoble I) “Ike Antkare, His Publications and Those of His Disciples”
- Burkhard Morgenstern (Universität Göttingen, Bioinformatics) “Virtual Editors Can Significantly Improve the Visibility of Junk Journals – A case study”
- Paul Brookes (University of Rochester, Medicine) “Crossing the Line – Pseudonyms & Snark in Post-Pub Peer Review”